Insurance Payments

Your Insurance payments can be conveniently made in one of the following manners:

- Mailing the payment directly to the company your insurance is through.

- Mailing the payment to your local Thorne Insurance office.

- Calling the company your policy is with directly at phone numbers listed below or calling your local Thorne Insurance office.

- Or to pay online please click on the Company website below that your insurance is through.

Company Links

If you would like to make a payment directly to a company use the links below. You may need additional information from your bill to create an account with the company.

Company Payments Website Payments Number
Western Reserve Group Website Call: 877-566-0699
Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company Website Call: 800-666-6460
Erie Insurance Website Call: 800-387-1492
Goodville Mutual Casualty Company
American Modern Website Call: 800-543-2644
Arlington/Roe & Co Call: 800-878-9891
Auto-Owners Insurance Company Website Call: 800-288-8740
Celina Insurance Group Website Call: 800-552-5181
Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance Company Call: Not available at this time
Foremost Website Call: Auto - 888-888-0080 / All Other - 800-527-3905
Hagerty Website Call: 877-922-9701
Pro Ag Call: Not available at this time
Progressive Auto Insurance Website Call: 800-776-4737
State Auto Insurance Companies Website Call: 800-444-9950

Let Us Contact You About a Quote!

We believe that every new policy begins with a relationship with a trusted advisor. Our agents are trained to work with you to get you the coverages you need as well as educate you on the products available.

Your Information

Name *
Phone *
Nearest Office *

Products Interested In

Interested In *

Additional Comments

Additional Information
* Required
  • Huntington: 260-468-2953
    Huntington Office

    Thorne Insurance Agency Inc.

    8699 S 700 W
    Warren, IN 46792

    Phone: 260-468-2953

    Alt Phone: 260-468-5221

    Toll Free: 877-464-1044

    Fax: 260-468-2954

    More Info

  • Wabash: 260-563-2000
    Wabash Office

    Thorne Insurance Agency Wabash Inc.

    693 N Cass Street
    Wabash, IN 46992

    Phone: 260-563-2000

    Alt Phone: 260-563-9000

    Toll Free: 866-457-2175

    Fax: 260-563-3399

    More Info

  • North Manchester: 260-982-2881
    North Manchester Office

    Thorne Insurance Agency, Inc.

    114 W Main St
    North Manchester, IN 46962

    Phone: 260-982-2881

    Toll Free: 800-932-2881

    Fax: 260-982-2871

    More Info

  • Warsaw: 574-269-3600
    Warsaw Office

    Thorne Insurance Morton Agency

    PO Box 991
    Warsaw, IN 46581

    Phone: 574-269-3600

    Fax: 260-982-2881

    More Info

  • New Paris: 574-831-4461
    New Paris Office

    16173 County Rd 46
    New Paris, IN 46553

    Phone: 574-831-4461

    Fax: 574-831-4461

    More Info